The way twitter responded to the event threw up some interesting areas to ponder.
- How could a journalist new to twitter build a network that would key them in to this kind of thing?
- How much the discussion on twitter must have been like a the discussion in the newsroom
- How amazing networks are.
The way the network raised Athar in to the view of more than just his own part of the twitterverse is explored in an interesting article by Steve Myers who traces back through his own network to try and get to where Athar came from.
But it’s the followup article (whose title I hijacked for the title of this one) that caught my attention. Myers writes:
When I wrote earlier this week about how quickly people around the world learned that Sohaib Athar had “live tweeted” the raid on Osama bin Laden’s compound, I thought carefully before calling him a citizen journalist.
He was prompted to explore that further by an article refuting the claim that twitter has replaced CNN by Dan Mitchell.
Steve Myers of The Poynter Institute declares that Sohaib Athar, a guy who lives near bin Laden’s compound, is a “citizen journalist.” Athar, an IT consultant, wondered what the hell was going on when the helicopters arrived in Abbottabad. Because he wondered on Twitter, in real time, now he’s a “citizen journalist.”
Even Athar, who had 750 followers as of Sunday night and now has tens of thousands,knows this is ridiculous.
Indeed. Although I think Mitchell uses Athars tweet (below) a little out of context to suit his point.
All of the articles are worth a read. Myers deconstruction of Athar’s tweets is particularly good. But there is one thing that is ignored. It’s alluded to. But never asked. Does Athar care?
Does Athar care that he is a citizen journalist or otherwise? Is it important to him.
Pondering that one just reinforces my view that the only people who have a problem with the phrase are the people who use it most – journalists.
I did tweet Athar to ask him if he thought he was a citizen journalist. I don’t expect an answer. His twitter stream make it clear that he’s very busy with interviews.
I suppose one thing you can say for certain in that whether or not he’s a citizen journalist he’s certainly a celebrity.
- Live-blogging the Raid on Osama bin Laden’s House (6thfloor.blogs.nytimes.com)
- Osama bin Laden’s death shows impact of Twitter (reportr.net)
- Sohaib Athar: The Guy Who Live-Tweeted Osama Bin Laden’s Death (observer.com)
- “AMAZIAN OF THE WEEK! @ReallyVirtual, The Man Who Unwittingly Live-Tweeted The Raid On Osama bin Laden” and related posts (disgrasian.com)